Psychotherapy, Preaching and Self-Differentiation in Ministry

middle aged woman talking to psychologistThere is a term in psychology that every preacher needs to be aware of called “self-differentiation” and it basically means knowing where you stop and everyone else starts…it is the maturity to be able to pull apart what is going on inside of self and what is going on outside yourself. Part of self-differentiation in ministry is being aware of where you have come from…your family, heritage, upbringing, early church experience, etc and how those experiences and ministries influence your feelings, decisions and even your preaching. Understanding these things helps one understand where they are coming from in addressing the congregation and enables one to make a clearer distinction between what is one’s own personal issue and what are the actually issues of a given community of faith.

When it comes to preaching it is very easy to blur these lines and make the pulpit a place to try to work out our own issues due to not having a strong enough sense of self-differentiation. If we aren’t careful we can project our own issues, our own sin and our own interests onto everyone else. The sermon becomes an unfolding and awkward event where the congregation is inadvertently led through an intervention for the preacher by the preacher or where the church is led through an intervention that is subconsciously aimed at a congregation from a previous ministry left with unresolved issues. It seems to obvious to even have to say but not all of our issues are the church’s issues and not all of the church’s issues must be our issues…it is important that we take the time to understand the differences. Not understanding this and unloading our issues on the church is a dangerous move that I don’t think is even done on purpose…but is driven more by our subconscious.

Before we can understand others we must make an effort to understand ourselves.

A few examples
A while back I heard a minister talking about the 13 week series he had just wrapped up on some very obscure biblical topic and he concluded that “everyone absolutely loved it.” Maybe that is the case but I bet equally likely is the possibility that he had projected his own love and interest in the topic and getting to teach it to their interest level and love of the topic. The two don’t always match and it takes some maturity to figure out when things don’t line up and why.

I have seen ministers make a big deal out of issues that later were publically revealed as their own personal issues. For instance, there have been ministers who have railed against homosexuality who later were found out to struggle with that personally.

Two more words…
Here are two more words from the field of psychology that are useful in therapy but also useful in understanding how we preach and why we preach what we preach. These words are transference and counter-transference. In psychotherapy transference is when the patient directs feelings toward the therapist. They may see the therapist as the father/mother figure they never had and try to use that relationship in an unhealthy way to mend problems of the past.The flip side of that is counter-transference…where the therapist directs their own inner feelings and issues onto the patient.

How does this play out in preaching? These two words are the nuts and bolts of how someone with weak self-differentiation works out their issues in real time. It is easy to take a congregation and direct issues from past congregations at an entirely new set of people in order to work out our own personal issues. It is equally possible for counter-transference to take place in the church…where the congregation directs their feelings toward past ministers and elders toward someone new who had nothing to do with their past issues.

The power of scripture
Hebrews 4:12-13 says, “For the word of God is alive and active. Sharper than any double-edged sword, it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow; it judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart. Nothing in all creation is hidden from God’s sight. Everything is uncovered and laid bare before the eyes of him to whom we must give account.”

As we study scripture in preparation to preach it is only natural that God’s Word will draw out of us and unearth within us our past, unresolved issues. It is vitally important that we personally deal with those things as they arrive. But we must be aware that just because a given verse or point punches us in the gut doesn’t mean that we have to lean on that point to punch the congregation in the gut as well…while it might make for an attempt at powerful rhetoric…it isn’t the fair thing to do.

Understanding ourselves can help us avoid working out our own personal issues on the church. People don’t attend to be psychoanalyzed by the preacher much less be your therapist as you work out your issues before a live studio audience.

Borrowing imagination…

will only take you so far. There are more good (and bad) resources (blogs, books, audio/video, etc) available today than any other point in history. What is at least as significant is that these resources are more accessible than ever before (often instant). Unfortunately that means I can easily make a living off borrowed imaginationContinue Reading

One Thing More Fearful Than Our Fear of Death

Genesis 3:1-7, Now the serpent was more crafty than any of the wild animals the Lord God had made. He said to the woman, “Did God really say, ‘You must not eat from any tree in the garden’?” The woman said to the serpent, “We may eat fruit from the trees in the garden, butContinue Reading

Logos Review: Crossway Apologetics Collection (10 Vols)

A few months ago I started teaching a lesson series on Apologetics in my Wednesday night class. I began picking up as many resources as I could in advance of teaching this class so that I would really know what I was talking about. It seems to me there is a lot of misinformation outContinue Reading

3 Core Values and How They Work Together: Spiritual, Mutual and Missional

This has been percolating in my brain for the last year or so and things are finally starting to gel and take shape. A few years ago I ran into the idea of Core Values, Ethos and Practice from Hirsch’s book “On the Verge.” The basic idea is that every organization has a set ofContinue Reading

The Prayers of Hallelujah, Hurts and Hates

I have been reading a lot on prayer lately and ran across this point from Eugene Peterson in his terrific little book on prayer, “Answering God: The Psalms as Tools for Prayer,” It is easy to be honest before God with our hallelujah’s; it is somewhat more difficult to be honest in our hurts; itContinue Reading

Walking in the Light, the Grace of God and Liberation from the Rat Race of Earning It

I got up early this morning to go on a long run. About 5 miles in I was crossing the street in the dark and tripped over the sidewalk sliding on my hands and knees. Turns out there wasn’t a curb cut there to transition from the street back onto the sidewalk but I couldn’tContinue Reading

Our Desperate Need to Lean Into This Gospel Truth – The World Is Overcome In You

For those of you who are struggling…who are tired…who feel like the world is out to get you…be encouraged by these words starting in John 16:33, “ I have said these things to you, that in me you may have peace. In the world you will have tribulation. But take heart; I have overcome the world.”Continue Reading

Yertle the Turtle, Greco-Roman Meals and Jesus

The great poet and part-time theologian Doctor Seuss told the story about societal pecking orders, abuse of authority and how complex systems of hegemony and hierarchy can come crashing down by the simple acts of the little guy at the bottom of the pile. The story is Yertle the turtle. The antagonist is King YertleContinue Reading

Asserting Our Rights

We had a busy weekend…so busy that there was one event we had to drive separately to because Missy had to be at something else before that and we just couldn’t drive together. On the way home Missy was driving her car right in the right lane and I was in the left. I noticedContinue Reading